Founded in 2022 by Arpan Kalotra and Bhimsinh Ghanghal—two pastoralists from the Maldhari community—Panchal Dairy produces and retails artisanal cheese made out of goat and sheep milk in Sayla, located in the Surendranagar district of Gujarat. They source milk directly from local pastoralists who follow traditional livestock-rearing practices. Their current range of products includes both fresh and aged cheeses—goat milk cheeses like feta, halloumi, and Tomme de Sayla, and specialty sheep milk cheeses like ricotta, roquefort, and pecorino.
Most conventional dairies in and around Surendranagar only accept goat or sheep milk from the pastoral communities when it is mixed with cow or buffalo milk. This is because dairies typically refuse anything other than cow milk, owing to the absence of a dedicated market for non-bovine goat and sheep milk. While pastoralists produce milk in significant quantities, a lack of separate collection or value chain systems for sheep and goat milk means that they have little choice but to channel it through the existing dairy market dominated by cow and buffalo milk.
Panchal Dairy was established to address this gap, and create livelihoods for pastoralist communities in the region. They work with a small network of partner farmers and goat rearers, including both men and women, depending on the milk available and number of pre-orders.
These pastoralists follow traditional herding practices wherein they ensure that the kids and lambs get an ample supply of milk before manually milking the goats and sheep. They also follow traditional migration routes which allow their herds to feed on native plants such as babul, khejri, kumath, gorad, kerdo, and neem, resulting in nutrient-rich milk.
Today, Panchal Dairy sources milk from six families who have a total herd size of 400 goats and 200 sheep; the dairy pays them more than the average market rate which is typically ₹25 per litre for goat milk, and ₹38 per litre for sheep milk. Panchal Dairy pays their pastoralists ₹40 and ₹45 rupees per litre for goat and sheep milk, respectively.
The Locavore Stamp
The Locavore Stamp offers a closer look at how Panchal Dairy works—not just what they produce, but the practices, choices, and compromises they make, and their relationships with the people growing the food. We look at their work through seven interconnected lenses: Origin, Knowledge, Workforce, Production, Composition, Packaging, and Community. Together, these form a single food landscape, reflecting how none of these aspects exists in isolation.
Traditional certifications rely on defined standards and thresholds, but these can sometimes leave less room for the nuance of how a producer actually operates. The Locavore Stamp is intended to make more of that complexity visible rather than reduce a producer to a pass, fail, or score. It is a way to make a producer’s practices more transparent, recognise where meaningful work is being done, acknowledge where there may still be room to improve, and give you greater context to be able to decide whether and how you might support it.
What follows is a snapshot of Panchal Dairy at the time of publication, based on our research and several rounds of conversations with Arpan Kalotra.
Hover or tap on the illustration above to explore the seven lenses of The Locavore Stamp. Illustration by Antara Raman.
Origin
Panchal Dairy sources milk from six herder families, based in three villages in the Sayla block of Surendranagar district in Gujarat.
Knowledge
Panchal Dairy promotes traditional rearing techniques like mobile livestock grazing and milking animals by hand.
Workforce
Currently, only the founders are involved full-time; they do not draw a salary.
Production
The sheep and goats graze freely on open graze tracts which helps in seed dispersal, and in turn, supports regrowth and regeneration of the land .
Composition
While natural rennet—curdled milk from the stomach of an unweaned calf—is incorporated in the making of cheese, no artificial additives are used.
Packaging
Cheese is shipped in plastic containers with ice packs cushioned in a styrofoam box.
Community
Panchal Dairy supports their partner herders with veterinary care and vaccinations for their animals.
Why We Love Panchal Dairy
-
Close relationships with local pastoralists: Before Panchal Dairy was established, women from the Maldhari community offered Arpan and Bhimsinh financial support. Now, Panchal Dairy sources milk from these women and their families. They have formed trust-based relationships with them where they pay them more than the average market rate for the milk. They also collect milk depending on what is available, considering unweaned kids and lambs also feed on their mothers’ milk.
- Preserving traditional herding practices: Earlier, before the introduction of canals and other water bodies in the region, local pastoralists would rely on migration—from the onset of summer to the arrival of monsoon—to locate water resources and grazing tracts for their herds. These migration routes spanning thousands of kilometres across states—from Gujarat to Maharashtra and even Tamil Nadu—have been passed down over generations. Panchal Dairy sources milk from pastoralists who continue to follow traditional migration routes. The herds feed on native plants across the routes which helps prevent overgrazing and also results in nutritious milk that is distinct in flavour, reflecting what the herds feed on.
-
Small-batch production to avoid wastage: Panchal Dairy collects milk daily, at 8 am, which is then tested and sent for processing in Sayla. The cheesemaking process goes on until 2 pm, after which the cheese is aged. Their cheese is made on a pre-order basis to avoid wastage, and in instances of limited pre-orders and excess milk, they resort to making aged cheeses which have a longer shelf life.
Have you noticed a shift in people’s perception towards goat and sheep milk products, and pastoral practices in recent years? How do you envision this changing in the future?
“There has definitely been a gradual shift. The market for processed cheese in India has developed significantly over the past 5–8 years. Today, cheese is accessible almost everywhere—pizzas and pastas that use it have become quite common. As a result, people’s tastes are slowly evolving and adapting to these flavours.
You can see this within families too—while parents may have taken time to get used to it, the younger generation is far more open and often enjoys cheeses and new dairy products. This is a positive direction, and it gives hope that in the future there will be greater openness and a larger market for diverse dairy products, including those made from goat and sheep milk.”
—Arpan Kalotra, Co-founder of Panchal Dairy
Products We Recommend
How to Buy
If you would like to learn more about Panchal Dairy, or try their products, check out their website. If you’re interested in supporting them in other ways, please contact us at connect@thelocavore.in.
This is a paid partnership with Panchal Dairy. At The Locavore, we strive to keep the practices of a producer transparent and honest across all forms of partnerships.
Yashvi Shah is the Senior Partnerships Copywriter at The Locavore. In her free time, she likes creating playlists for her friends, and going on runs.
Neil Khopkar is the Partnerships Lead at The Locavore. Trained in culinary arts and business, his interests range from gastronomy to music.
Editor: Yamini Vijayan
Copy Editor: Khorshed Deboo
Share this:
- Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
- Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
- Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
- Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
- Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
- Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
- Click to print (Opens in new window) Print